Straight from The Belly|| January 24, 2006 @ 10:48 pm || Major League Soccer
That Major League Soccer so often screws up even the simplest of things is an ongoing theme of this blog. But if I’m going to continue to criticize and rant about the league’s faults (as I surely intend) then perhaps I also bear some responsibility to offer the league the occasional bit of positive advice.
I see your eyes rolling now. “Not this crap again.” But, no, I swear I’m not going to say anything about going single table, disbanding the playoff system, or instituting promotion and relegation. I agree with you, my sensible readers. The people who constantly whine about talk passionately in favor of such things are completely detached from the realities of soccer in the United States. They are the American soccer equivalent of the Flat Earth Society.
Nor am I going to suggest that MLS write some big checks for big name players in the misguided tradition of the NASL. As far as I’m concerned this proposed Beckham rule and this guy’s column over at the usually top-notch ussoccerplayers.com are both a bunch of baloney. And by baloney I mean hooey.
Nope, I’m going in an entirely different direction with my advice. Two principles guide me here. First, MLS is cheap. I will consider MLS cheap, indeed profoundly cheap, as long as MLS teams still find themselves out-bid for blue-collar players by the USL First Division. The second principle, in keeping with my favorite theme, is that one should never underestimate the league’s aptitude for screwing up the simple things. They couldn’t even manage to hide the Houston 1836 logo from the guys at BigSoccer. That’s why you’ve gotta keep it simple and cheap when giving advice to MLS.
Here’s my first bit of simple and cheap advice: Set up an away supporters section at every single game.
I’ve attended a number of away games in my life, sometimes with a large group and sometimes with just one or two other like-minded fans. In a group we’re loud and boisterous; some would call us downright obnoxious. Either way we have a blast and we certainly bring some atmosphere to the stadium.
In Major League Soccer it’s not every game that you get a good, large and vocal group of opposition supporters in your home stadium. But when you do people genuinely enjoy the atmosphere they bring.
With small groups the effect is more muted. Much, much more muted. And it’s not as much fun.
Pain in the keister. That’s what it is to organize large groups of away supporters. I know. I have done it several times for DC United fans living in exile on the West Coast. It would be much easier if MLS teams had pre-established away sections at all the games.
When you call up the ticket office the first thing they should ask is if you’re a home or away supporter. Then, if you say you’re an away supporter, they should ask if you’d like to sit in the away supporter’s section. It wouldn’t matter if you’re a lone ex-pat looking to make the most of your one chance all year to support your team in person, or if you’re a big, organized supporters club looking to purchase a whole block of tickets. If you’re an away supporter, and if you so desire, MLS teams should do everything possible to seat you with other away supporters.
Want atmosphere at MLS stadiums? Want to sell the game in the United States? Then make it easier for away fans to sit together. No matter whether they antagonize them or inspire them, nothing makes home supporters better than visible and vocal away supporters. Their presence improves the entire game day experience.
Away supporters sections. It’s simple and it’s cheap. MLS will never do it.
I think that many teams have an idea about where they would like to put the away supporters. DC fans are always in the same corner when they go to Chicago and NJ (not sure if this is SE and BB knowing where they want to be or the teams telling them). DC always puts away supporters groups up in the same 200 level corner every time they travel to RFK. There are a few problems however, but they are not insurmountable.
The first is that there is no place non-group sales away supporters section. This is a point that I think you are trying to rectify (or atleast shed light on) and I agree with you. However, once you decide to have an away group section you still have ticketmaster sales or game day sales and other non-MLS sold tickets that you have to deal with.
Another issue is that you do not want to give good seats to away supporters. Especially when there is only one side with stands behind the goals. So the away supporters are going to be put in a corner on the other side of the stadium in really bad seats.
Not a problem, until you realize as an away supporter that with a little bit of planning you can get a group of seats at the 50 yard line. Think about what happened at the 2004 MLS Cup where they did have away supporters sections. The DC fans said “screw the supporters sections, were going to go behind the goal” and were much more visable because of it.
Again, not deal breaking problems, but stuff that complicates it a little bit.
Comment by colonial717 — January 25, 2006 @ 2:56 pm
There is no logical reason why MLS shouldn’t take your suggestion. But maybe logic doesn’t come into play. How about tricking them into thinking this was their idea?
Cool site.
Comment by J. Michael — January 25, 2006 @ 3:34 pm
J. Michael - Thanks for the compliment. Interesting blog you’ve got there yourself. (Now if the blogsome server would stop being so buggy …)
Colonial1717 - I believe that is SE and BB making those arrangements. And some stadiums probably do put away supporters clubs in the same place every time. (HDC doesn’t, Spartan didn’t. Don’t know about other places.)
It’s true you don’t want to hold good seats for away fans who may or may not materialize. But at this point teams can probably anticipate the kind of away crowds they’ll get. Again, at HDC Chivas and the Galaxy both know they’re going to get up to two dozen away fans whenever United is in town. (And if Rimando’s family shows up, considerably more.)
Now Ticketmaster and day of game sales are a problem. But if you could get most of the away supporters sitting together that’d be an improvement.
Obviously some highly organized away groups (BB and SE) will go their own way. But, again, teams should be able to anticipate that and establish away sections accordingly.
You’re right. None of these things are deal breakers, but the do complicate things. That’s too bad. I don’t have much confidence in MLS doing complicated things.
Comment by The Belly — January 25, 2006 @ 5:14 pm
I totally agree that it would be good to have, but I’m afraid it goes in the same category as pro/rel and single table.
Try walking up to a big stadium in England on the day of the game and getting a ticket. I’ve never been, but I’ve heard that the only way to get a ticket is from the supporters’ club, not from the team. That basically means that all the seats are sold to the supporters’ clubs and then resold to fans.
MLS teams don’t have that kind of supporters’ club. Heck, most teams don’t even have a good relationship with their supporters’ clubs (as I understand it, the Earthquakes/ClubQuake was the only one where the team GM and the club president were in direct contact, and a rep from the team attended every club board meeting).
Bill Ward (Webmaster, ClubQuake)
Comment by Bill — January 25, 2006 @ 9:44 pm